Best combination of indicators without repainting

Posted by

When trading or analyzing markets, one of the key challenges is finding technical indicators that provide accurate, reliable signals without “repainting.” Repainting occurs when an indicator’s value changes after the fact, often leading to false signals or misleading past data. To avoid this, it’s important to focus on non-repainting indicators.

Here’s a list of effective combinations of indicators that do not repaint:

1. Moving Averages + RSI (Relative Strength Index)

Why it works:

Moving Averages (MA): Moving averages, particularly the Simple Moving Average (SMA) or Exponential Moving Average (EMA), help determine the trend’s direction. These indicators don’t repaint because their values are based on historical data, not on real-time fluctuations.
RSI: The RSI is a momentum oscillator that shows if an asset is overbought or oversold. It typically ranges from 0 to 100. A common combination is using a 14-period RSI, with levels set at 30 (oversold) and 70 (overbought).

How to combine:

Use the MA to determine the trend (e.g., price above a 50-period EMA suggests an uptrend).
Use RSI to time entries. When the price is in an uptrend (above the moving average) and RSI crosses above 30 from below, it’s a potential buying signal.
In a downtrend (price below the moving average), RSI crossing below 70 from above might suggest a good selling point.

2. MACD (Moving Average Convergence Divergence) + Stochastic Oscillator

Why it works:

MACD: The MACD is a trend-following momentum indicator that calculates the difference between two EMAs (usually the 12-period and 26-period) and a signal line (9-period). It is a non-repainting indicator that helps identify changes in trend direction, momentum, and market strength.
Stochastic Oscillator: This is another momentum oscillator that compares the closing price of an asset to its price range over a specified period. It’s particularly useful for spotting overbought and oversold conditions and it doesn’t repaint.

How to combine:

Look for a MACD crossover (when the MACD line crosses above the signal line) as a trend change signal.
Use the Stochastic Oscillator to filter the signals: A Stochastic reading above 80 suggests overbought, while below 20 suggests oversold.
A bullish signal can occur when MACD crosses above the signal line while Stochastic is below 20 (oversold) and moving upward.

3. Bollinger Bands + Volume

Why it works:

Bollinger Bands: Bollinger Bands consist of a middle SMA and two standard deviation bands above and below it. This indicator doesn’t repaint because it is based on the actual closing prices and doesn’t change as time progresses.
Volume: Volume indicates the strength of a price movement. High volume during price moves can confirm the trend’s validity, while low volume suggests a lack of conviction.

How to combine:

Use Bollinger Bands to identify periods of high volatility (when the price touches or breaks the outer bands).
Look for Volume spikes that accompany moves outside the bands. If price breaks the upper band with high volume, it can signal a continuation of the uptrend, and vice versa for a breakdown.
A bounce from the lower Bollinger Band with increasing volume can be a strong buy signal in an uptrend.

4. Donchian Channels + ADX (Average Directional Index)

Why it works:

Donchian Channels: Donchian Channels are a simple trend-following indicator that plots the highest high and the lowest low over a specified period. It doesn’t repaint because it’s based on historical high and low prices.
ADX: The ADX measures the strength of a trend (ranging from 0 to 100). It doesn’t indicate the direction of the trend, only its strength. It helps to filter trades based on trend strength.

How to combine:

Use Donchian Channels to identify breakout points. When the price breaks above the upper channel, it indicates a potential upward trend, and vice versa for downward breakouts.
Confirm the strength of the trend with ADX. If ADX is above 25, the trend is considered strong, and the breakout from the Donchian Channel is more likely to continue.

5. Ichimoku Cloud + Parabolic SAR

Why it works:

Ichimoku Cloud: The Ichimoku Cloud is a comprehensive indicator that provides information about support/resistance, trend direction, and momentum. It is made up of five lines, and it is known for not repainting as its values are based on fixed historical data.
Parabolic SAR (Stop and Reverse): The Parabolic SAR is a trend-following indicator that provides potential entry and exit points. It does not repaint because it only uses past price data to place dots above or below the price.

How to combine:

Use Ichimoku Cloud to determine the overall trend. If the price is above the cloud, the trend is bullish, and if it’s below, the trend is bearish.
The Parabolic SAR can be used to identify entry points. A buy signal occurs when the dots move below the price (indicating a potential upward trend), and a sell signal happens when the dots are above the price (indicating a potential downtrend).
Together, they help confirm whether the price is trending and when to enter or exit the market.

Key Takeaways

Avoid Repainting: Ensure that the indicators used are based on historical data (not recalculated with new data), which ensures their values do not change after the fact.
Use Trend-Following Indicators: MAs, MACD, and Ichimoku Cloud are great for identifying the current trend.
Momentum Oscillators for Timing Entries: RSI, Stochastic, and ADX help time when the market is overbought or oversold.
Use Volume for Confirmation: Volume spikes can confirm the validity of signals, especially with indicators like Bollinger Bands.

By combining trend-following and momentum indicators that don’t repaint, you can create a reliable strategy that helps minimize false signals. The key is consistency, backtesting, and adapting these combinations to suit your trading style.