Scalping has become an increasingly popular trading strategy, especially with the rise of automated trading systems known as Expert Advisors (EAs). Scalping EAs are programmed to open and close trades within minutes or even seconds to capture small profits repeatedly throughout the day. But is using scalping EAs an effective trading approach or just risky business? This comprehensive guide examines the pros and cons of using scalping EAs for ultra short-term trading.
What is Scalping and How Do Scalping EAs Work?
Scalping refers to a trading style that involves opening and closing numerous trades throughout a single trading session to profit from small price movements. Scalping traders typically aim to earn profits of 5-10 pips per trade and close positions within minutes or even seconds after entry.
Scalping EAs (also called scalper bots) are automated trading systems that are programmed to implement scalping strategies. They open and close trades automatically based on parameters set by the trader, such as:
- Entry and exit rules
- Position sizing
- Stop loss and take profit levels
Scalping EAs monitor the markets, identify trading opportunities based on technical indicators or price action, then rapidly enter and exit trades. They can scan for trading setups and execute them much faster than a human trader could manually.
The goal is to capture small, frequent profits that add up over time. Scalping EAs aim to profit from minor volatility and trends through high trade frequency and speed of order execution.
The Potential Benefits of Using Scalping EAs
There are some potential advantages to using scalping EAs rather than manually scalping:
Faster Reaction Time
Scalping EAs can scan for trading opportunities and enter/exit positions much faster than a human trader can analyze charts and place orders. This allows them to capitalize on even small, short-term market movements.
Consistent Strategy Execution
Scalping EAs consistently apply the exact same strategy 24/7 without fatigue or distraction. Humans cannot realistically scalp markets round-the-clock without performance deterioration over time.
Scalping EAs can handle trading multiple currency pairs or order sizes simultaneously, allowing larger position sizes and profit potential. Humans can only realistically scalp a few pairs at once.
Low Trading Drawdowns
By closing losing trades quickly with tight stops, scalping EAs can potentially reduce drawdowns versus other trading strategies with wider stops.
Potential Risks of Scalping EAs to Consider
However, there are also notable risks involved in using scalping EAs:
Scalping EAs can be over-optimized to historical price data, producing great backtest results but failing in live trading. They must be robustly tested to avoid this pitfall.
Increased Trading Costs
The high trade frequency of scalping EAs leads to accumulated trading fees and spread costs that eat into profits. These costs really add up over time.
Difficulties During Low Volatility
With less price fluctuation, it becomes harder for scalping EAs to generate profitable trades. They may have extended losing streaks during low volatility conditions when the market is ranging.
Vulnerability to Slippage
Entering and exiting positions rapidly makes scalping EAs vulnerable to slippage beyond limits assumed during backtesting. This can diminish profits in live trading.
Scalping EAs still require monitoring in case of errors or changing market conditions. Lack of oversight can lead to large unintended losses.
The ability to trade larger position sizes with scalping EAs poses risks if they are overleveraged. Losses can snowball quickly, even with tight stops.
It’s tempting to over-optimize scalping EAs, curve-fitting them excessively to past price data. This often leads to failure in live trading environments.
Key Factors to Consider in Scalping EA Trading
The success of a scalping EA depends greatly on how well it is designed, optimized, and incorporated into a robust trading plan. Here are some key factors to consider:
Robust Backtesting Across Various Market Conditions
Proper backtesting across many years and market environments is essential to evaluate a scalping EA. Beware of over-optimization and seek out-of-sample testing.
Cautious Use of Leverage
While scalping EAs allow bigger position sizes, leverage should be used conservatively to limit risk. Margin calls can happen quickly with small stop losses.
Narrow Focus on Specific Currency Pairs and Sessions
Limiting scalping EAs to a few currency pairs and trading sessions where conditions align well with their logic can improve performance.
Balancing Profit Targets with Trading Costs
Profit targets must exceed round-turn trading costs while allowing the EA enough winning trades to be profitable long-term.
Coding Quality and Parameters
The EA’s programming code quality and optimization of inputs/settings impacts results. Poor coding can cause unexpected losses.
Strong Risk Management Strategies
Tight stop losses, position sizing rules, and exposure limits should be implemented to restrict risk with frequent trades.
Combining scalping EAs with other trading strategies can potentially smooth equity curves and improve risk-adjusted returns.
Ongoing Monitoring and Updates
Regular monitoring and incremental improvement of scalping EAs is required to adapt to changing market conditions over time.
Scalping EAs dependent on too many technical indicators or complex logic are prone to curve-fitting and live trading issues. Simplicity is best.
Scalping EA Success Stories
There are certainly traders who have managed to achieve consistent success with scalping EAs:
- Andrea: Claims to earn $500 – $2000 per day scalping small moves in the EUR/USD and GBP/USD. Uses a self-coded basic RSI/stochastics scalping EA with a 70% yearly ROI.
- Lee: Trades a commercial scalping EA on the M1 timeframe focused on GBP and CHF pairs. Reports average profits of 4-7 pips per trade and 50-100 trades daily with a 65% win rate.
- Ryan: Combines manual and EA scalping techniques. His EAs target 10-15 pips per trade on the M5 chart of EUR/USD, USD/CAD, and AUD/USD. He has earned 20-40% annual returns over 3 years.
- Kira: Uses multiple scalping EAs based purely on price action rather than indicators. Trades EUR/JPY and USD/JPY on the M15 timeframe, profiting 3-8 pips per trade. Claims to make $1000 per week after costs.
However, for every scalping EA success, there are probably twenty more traders who lose money attempting to use these systems profitably. Careful design, testing, and risk management is required.
6 Key Questions to Ask Before Trading a Scalping EA
If you are evaluating potential scalping EAs, here are 6 essential questions to ask:
1. How thoroughly has the scalping EA been backtested?
- Rigorous backtesting over many years of historical data is vital to gauge performance across different market conditions. Beware of limited testing periods.
2. What is the risk management like?
- Scalping EAs need tight stop losses, limits on position sizing, and exposure caps to control risk given their high volume of trades.
3. How complex is the trading logic?
- Overly complex EAs with numerous filters and parameters tend to be over-optimized and fail in live trading. Simple, discretionary logic is better.
4. How does it handle different market conditions?
- Check for drawdowns and losing streaks during low volatility or ranging markets. The EA should trade well in all environments.
5. What pairs and sessions will it trade?
- Optimizing the EA for specific currency pairs and sessions is preferable over attempting to scalp all markets 24/7.
6. Does the backtest include trading costs and slippage?
- Raw backtest results must be adjusted for spreads, commissions, and slippage to provide realistic expectations. Ignore marketing hype.
Carefully researching the EA developer, design philosophy, parameters, and backtest results can give you reasonable confidence in a scalping EA before committing real capital. Never rely purely on simulated backtest results.
The Bottom Line – Is Scalping with EAs Recommended?
Scalping EAs offer potential benefits like rapid automated trading, frequent small gains, and emotionless execution. However, the risks like over-optimization, increasing costs, slippage, and overleveraging are all formidable. Traders drawn to the excitement and profit potential of scalping robots should approach with realistic expectations and risk control.
For most retail traders, manually implementing a selective and patient short-term trading approach is likely better than trusting scalping EAs. But with rigorous testing and risk reduction, it’s certainly possible to succeed with automated scalping systems. As with any EA, expect long drawdowns and be ready to constantly monitor and improve the system over time.
Proceed with caution, manage risk wisely, and have reasonable expectations. While scalping EAs can provide a viable path to profits, they require extensive expertise to trade successfully – rarely will the promise of easy riches with scalper bots live up to reality. Do your due diligence in researching and robustly evaluating any scalping EA system before committing real capital.
Best and Most Trusted Forex Brokers
Based on regulation, award recognition, mainstream credibility, and overwhelmingly positive client feedback, these six brokers stand out for their sterling reputations:
|No||Broker||Regulation||Min. Deposit||Platforms||Account Types||Offer||Open New Account|
|1.||RoboForex||FSC Belize||$10||MT4, MT5, RTrader||Standard, Cent, Zero Spread||Welcome Bonus $30||Open RoboForex Account|
|2.||AvaTrade||ASIC, FSCA||$100||MT4, MT5||Standard, Cent, Zero Spread||Top Forex Broker||Open AvaTrade Account|
|3.||Exness||FCA, CySEC||$1||MT4, MT5||Standard, Cent, Zero Spread||Free VPS||Open Exness Account|
|4.||XM||ASIC, CySEC, FCA||$5||MT4, MT5||Standard, Micro, Zero Spread||20% Deposit Bonus||Open XM Account|
|5.||ICMarkets||Seychelles FSA||$200||MT4, MT5, CTrader||Standard, Zero Spread||Best Paypal Broker||Open ICMarkets Account|
|6.||XBTFX||ASIC, CySEC, FCA||$10||MT4, MT5||Standard, Zero Spread||Best USA Broker||Open XBTFX Account|
|7.||Vantage||ASIC, CySEC, FCA||$50||MT4, MT5||Standard, Cent, Zero Spread||20% Deposit Bonus||Open Vantage Account|
|8.||FXTM||FSC Mauritius||$10||MT4, MT5||Standard, Micro, Zero Spread||Welcome Bonus $50||Open FXTM Account|
|9.||FBS||ASIC, CySEC, FCA||$5||MT4, MT5||Standard, Cent, Zero Spread||100% Deposit Bonus||Open FBS Account|
|10.||Binance||DASP||$10||Binance Platforms||N/A||Best Crypto Broker||Open Binance Account|
|11.||TradingView||Unregulated||Free||TradingView||N/A||Best Trading Platform||Open TradingView Account|
“If you don't find a way to make money while you sleep, you will work until you die.”
- Warren Buffett
MOST POPULAR FOREX ROBOT
Number One Robot for Forex Trading.
Based on Price Action and Trend Analysis with Artificial Intelligence.
Works Best with EURUSD & XAUUSD.
You can use this EA on Multiple Accounts with Life Time Premium Support.
MyFXbook, FxBlue & Live Trading Verified.
Monthly Expected Profit is 20% to 200% with very Less Drawdown.
check daily trading result
We will post our trading result daily on our channel. Please join our channel for daily updates.